Auditing Google Search Results for Human Rights

Date
-
Speaker
Rochelle Terman, Assistant Professor of Political Science, University of Chicago
Location
Encina Hall West, Room 400
Abstract

Research on international norms emphasizes the role of information, but often relies on a key premise: that the messages produced by international actors reach intended audiences. Yet this assumption is rarely studied directly, leaving us with scant knowledge about what people actually learn when accessing information about norms like human rights. This research note reports findings from an audit of Google search for human rights queries across 146 countries and 70 languages. We find that search results vary markedly across countries, indicating that different users are directed to different resources about human rights. Some people receive information produced by prominent international organizations, while others learn about human rights mainly from governments and local publishers. These disparities likely reflect differences not only in the sources of content, but also in the substantive messages about human rights. Furthermore, we find that natural language—far more than any other factor—correlates strongly with variation in search results, suggesting a prominent “language barrier” to international human rights discourse. Our results have significant implications for debates surrounding norm diffusion and knowledge-production in world politics, while offering practical guidance for human rights advocates.

Biography

Rochelle Terman is an assistant professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of Chicago. She studies international norms, gender, and advocacy, with a focus on the Muslim world. Her current book project, Backlash: Defiance, Human Rights, and the Politics of Shame, investigates counter-productive consequences of global “naming and shaming” campaigns. The manuscript is based on her dissertation, which won the 2017 Merze Tate Award for the best dissertation in international relations, law, and politics from the American Political Science Association. Terman is also interested is computational social science, and teaches courses on machine learning, text analysis, and programming.

Terman earned her B.A. from the University of Chicago, and Ph.D. in Political Science with a designated emphasis in Gender & Women’s Studies from the University of California, Berkeley. She joins the University of Chicago from Stanford University, where she was a post-doc at the Center for International Security and Cooperation.